Exclusion and credit · · 8 min read
Should I use the foreign earned income exclusion or the foreign tax credit?
It depends mostly on the income tax where you live. Where local rates are at or above US rates, the foreign tax credit often gives the better result: it can remove the US tax on that income and builds credits you can carry back 1 year and forward 10 years. Where there is little or no local income tax, the exclusion, up to $132,900 for 2026, usually matters more. Many returns use both.
How each one works
The foreign earned income exclusion, claimed on Form 2555, removes foreign earned income from US tax up to $132,900 for 2026. It needs a tax home abroad and either 330 full days abroad in any twelve consecutive months or bona fide residence for an uninterrupted period that includes an entire tax year. It covers wages and self-employment income for work done abroad, and nothing else: pensions, interest, dividends, rent and gains stay taxable.
The foreign tax credit, claimed on Form 1116, works the other way round. The income stays on the return, the US tax on it is worked out, and the income tax you paid abroad on the same income is set against that US tax. It applies to every kind of foreign income that was taxed abroad, including pensions and investment income. The credit is limited to the US tax on your foreign income in each category, with general income such as wages kept apart from passive income such as interest and dividends.
The two side by side
Read across each row to see where the two differ. Most of the choice comes down to two rows: the kind of income you have, and how much income tax the country you live in charges on it.
| Foreign earned income exclusion (Form 2555) | Foreign tax credit (Form 1116) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Removes foreign earned income from US tax, up to $132,900 for 2026 | Sets income tax paid abroad against the US tax on the same income |
| Income it covers | Wages and self-employment income for work done abroad | Any foreign income taxed abroad, including pensions and investment income, by category |
| What it needs | A foreign tax home, plus 330 full days abroad in 12 months or bona fide residence | Foreign income tax actually paid or accrued on that income |
| Unused amounts | Lost: an unused exclusion does not carry over | Carried back 1 year and forward 10 years |
| Refundable child tax credit | Not available to anyone who files Form 2555 | Often available, depending on earned income |
| Self-employment tax | Not reduced | Not reduced |
| Usually suits | Little or no local income tax | Local income tax at or above US rates |
| Changing your mind | Revoking it bars choosing it again for 5 years without IRS approval | A switch from deducting to crediting foreign tax is possible within 10 years |
When the credit often works better
In countries where income tax rates are at or above US rates, the foreign tax paid on a salary is often more than the US tax on it. The credit can then remove the US tax on that income, and the excess becomes a carryover that can be used back 1 year and forward 10 years against US tax on foreign income in the same category. Those carryovers can matter later, for example after a move to a country with lower rates.
The credit also keeps the refundable part of the child tax credit within reach. Anyone who files Form 2555 cannot claim the additional child tax credit, worth up to $1,700 per child for 2026. A family using the credit instead can often claim it, depending on earned income and the rest of the return. And earnings that are not excluded still count as compensation for IRA contributions, which excluded earnings do not.
When the exclusion usually matters more
Where there is little or no local income tax, there is little foreign tax to credit, and the exclusion usually does more. An employee in a country with no income tax on salaries can often exclude most or all of their earnings, and may add the housing exclusion for housing costs above a base amount. The return still has to be filed, because the exclusion only exists once Form 2555 is attached.
The exclusion does not lower the rate on the income that is left. Under the stacking rule, income above the exclusion, and any investment income, is taxed at the rates that would apply if the excluded income were still on the return. Someone earning well above $132,900 can find the income above the line taxed at a higher rate than they expected.
Neither one touches self-employment tax. A freelancer who excludes all their profit can still owe 15.3% on net earnings, unless a totalization agreement assigns them to the social security system where they live. The foreign tax credit is set only against US income tax, so it does not reduce self-employment tax either.
Using both on one return
The two can be combined. A common return excludes earned income up to the limit and claims the credit for foreign tax on the earnings above it, and on pensions or investment income taxed abroad. The rule that ties them together is that foreign tax on income you excluded cannot also be credited or deducted; only the tax on the part that stays taxable in the US counts.
Why switching later has a cost
Once you claim the exclusion, the choice carries forward to later years until you revoke it. The IRS treats claiming the foreign tax credit on income you could have excluded, or claiming the additional child tax credit, in a later year as revoking it. After a revocation you cannot choose the exclusion again for 5 years without IRS approval, which means asking for a ruling.
So the first year's choice is worth working through with the next few years in view. We prepare the return both ways from your figures, compare the results, and set out in writing which one the return uses and why. These are the facts that usually decide it:
- The income tax rates where you live, on each kind of income
- Whether your income is salary, self-employment, pension or investment income
- Children who could qualify for the refundable child tax credit
- IRA contributions you want to make for the year
- Credits carried from earlier years, and any earlier choice of the exclusion
Official sources
- About Form 2555, Foreign Earned Income · IRS
- About Form 1116, Foreign Tax Credit · IRS
- Foreign tax credit · IRS
- Publication 514, Foreign Tax Credit for Individuals · IRS
- Publication 54, Tax Guide for U.S. Citizens and Resident Aliens Abroad · IRS
- Instructions for Schedule 8812 (Form 1040) · IRS
Checked against these sources on . General information about US filing requirements, stated for the tax year named. It does not take your own facts into account.
